Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their very own.
Turning innovation into patents? It may be an uphill battle. I perceive the stakes. The method is not nearly one concept — it is about managing a pipeline of concepts coming out of your engineering staff, R&D division and even exterior collaborators.
The hurdles are actual. Some concepts won’t meet the brink for novelty. Others might face robust patent examiners, resulting in pricey rejections. This leaves you dealing with crucial selections: “Ought to we push ahead or shift assets elsewhere?” Entrepreneurs face robust selections on a regular basis, so measuring the dangers is essential.
I’ve seen corporations pour tens of 1000’s into applications that go nowhere — assets that might have protected stronger concepts or fueled different development and improvement. But it surely would not need to be this manner. By leveraging insights like understanding your utility’s chance of favorable remedy, you may make smarter selections and keep away from wasted effort.
Over 25 years, I’ve labored with startups and established enterprises alike to navigate these challenges. I’ve seen what works and what would not. Right here, I am sharing my 5 efficient methods to enhance your odds of success.
Associated: How to Ensure High-Quality Patent Filings — 5 Key Steps for Portfolio Managers
5 keys to smoother, extra profitable patent prosecution
A shopper as soon as advised me, “We did not simply need patents — we needed patents that mattered.” That is the essence of a profitable patent technique: securing protection for innovations that align with enterprise targets and drive development.
To realize this, I all the time emphasize to:
-
Give attention to concepts with the next chance of enterprise worth
-
Predict the place your utility will land earlier than it’s filed
-
Tailor your techniques based mostly on examiner analytics
-
Monitor your patent portfolio with real-time insights
-
Construct households of patents round key innovation
Let’s discover methods to apply them.
1. Give attention to concepts with the next chance of enterprise worth
Step one to boosting your possibilities of securing a patent is figuring out concepts which can be actually price defending. Submitting too many purposes for half-baked ideas can drain your time and finances whereas filling your portfolio with concepts which will by no means maintain up or ship actual worth.
The answer? Begin by casting a large internet to assemble concepts throughout the enterprise, then refine them strategically. Bring your team together — engineers, inventors, patent counsel and enterprise decision-makers — to guage every concept’s novelty, feasibility, patentability, market potential and match together with your total enterprise technique.
Use instruments designed for innovation administration to streamline this course of and collect suggestions. Collaborative options, like simultaneous concept enhancing and suggestions monitoring, might help your staff rapidly zero in on essentially the most promising improvements. By specializing in high-value concepts that align with strategic targets, you may save time, reduce costs and guarantee your patent efforts drive actual enterprise worth.
Along with your greatest concepts in hand, the subsequent step is to provide them the most effective likelihood of success — beginning with predicting the place your utility may land within the patent workplace.
2. Predict the place your utility will land earlier than it’s filed
On the patent workplace, the place your utility lands could make or break your success. Functions are assigned to totally different teams specializing in particular applied sciences. A few of these teams have excessive allowance charges, whereas others are identified for an uphill battle. Give attention to the correct facet that can get to the favorable determination makers to rapidly shield your innovation whereas saving finances.
What in the event you might predict your utility’s vacation spot earlier than submitting? There are predictor instruments to investigate your utility’s content material to anticipate its doubtless project. This perception helps you refine claims or tweak terminology and deal with avoiding getting caught in a black gap, in the end lowering delays, saving prices and enhancing approval odds — very similar to the saying, “Figuring out what lies forward is half the battle.“
Whereas these instruments are invaluable, do not forget that no predictor ensures success. The subsequent problem lies in getting ready for a battle with the patent examiner assigned to your case.
Associated: 5 Benefits Patent Management Software Must Deliver
3. Tailor your techniques based mostly on examiner analytics
The assigned examiner can have a profound affect on its consequence with no actual alternative to modify to a unique decision-maker. Some examiners — like Janice Mooneyham, with an allowance rate of near zero (i.e., 1.64% allowance rate) — are notoriously difficult and typically dubbed “patent killers.” Dealing with such examiners ceaselessly ends in repeated rejections, protracted examination and escalating prices, making the trail to a granted patent way more arduous, if not statistically not possible.
Nevertheless, with examiner analytics instruments, you may get a previous look into your examiner. These instruments reveal key insights, like allowance charges, common workplace actions and typical prosecution timelines. As an illustration, in case your examiner averages six rounds of arguments with a 20% success price, you’ll be able to refine claims early or pivot to different stronger instances which can be extra prone to obtain the allowance.
Now, most examiners are cheap, however understanding when you will have a patent killer permits managing your whole portfolio with the angle of statistical perception. That is the place analytics develop into important.
4. Monitor your patent portfolio with real-time insights
A portfolio of patents is troublesome to quantify rapidly. As soon as your utility is submitted, monitoring updates from the patent workplace in your case turns into very important. Whereas this step would not immediately guarantee a profitable patent, it helps handle prosecution strategically.
As an illustration, monitoring the precise versus predicted rounds of arguments in patent prosecution can reveal when a case is headed for extended prosecution. So, if a case is in its fourth spherical of arguments however was anticipated to resolve in two for the assigned examiner, it is a clear sign to recalibrate your technique. Figuring out the foundation trigger is crucial — whether or not it is refining the claims, reevaluating your patent counsel or deciding to desert the applying altogether. Taking well timed corrective motion can save vital time and assets.
Nevertheless, patents not often stand alone — they’re typically a part of international households clustered round an preliminary submitting.
5. Construct households of patents round key improvements
Patents not often stand alone. A single patent filing typically generates a household of patents — a number of purposes filed in numerous nations capturing totally different features of your innovation. Household tree insights enable you align these filings globally, turning particular person wins into broader successes.
For instance, if a U.S. patent is granted after particular declare amendments, you should use that to information purposes in Europe or Asia, saving time and prices. Additionally, there might be persevering with purposes for various concepts from the preliminary submitting. I’ve seen corporations keep away from pricey mistakes by recognizing rejection patterns throughout jurisdictions and adjusting methods early.
With these instruments, you’ll be able to shut gaps, leverage successes and craft a constant, cost-effective international technique.
Associated: Weak Patent Management Could Lead to Disastrous Consequences for Your Business — Here’s How to Avoid Them
Play to win
Patent prosecution is not nearly getting by; it is about profitable. It is about reworking your greatest concepts into aggressive benefits that drive development and shield your market.
Successful takes greater than effort; it requires technique, precision and the correct instruments. Instruments present insights — predicting the place your utility may land, understanding examiner conduct and monitoring your portfolio in real-time.
However instruments alone aren’t sufficient. Success calls for:
-
Good technique: Prioritizing concepts and understanding when to pivot.
-
Staff alignment: Uniting decision-makers, inventors and authorized groups.
-
Knowledgeable execution: Drafting hermetic claims and responding successfully.
With the correct instruments and profitable mindset, you may make knowledgeable selections and safe high-impact patents.